Hey guys, I was playing a game of Tzeentch vs Seraphon yesterday. I had gone full alpha and teleported a (buffed) 40-man block of Saurus Warriors and a 6-man Ripper squad, who all made their charge, into some Tzeentch demon frontlines. As you may imagine this caused a few battleshocks, especially amoung some pink horrors. He rolled their battleshock and rolled a 1. Now, normally, they get D6 units back on a battleshock roll of 1, but in this case the unit was within 5" of my Saurus Warriors' banner. This meant he had to add 1 to his battleshock roll. We then disagreed on whether my banner negated his ability to return D6 models, his argument being, that he had in fact rolled a 1 as required by the wording of the Pink Horror scroll. Any input?