Not exactly, to be more precise... Several people have shown that PF "should" work with SA because PF could work with SA. Several other people...
First of all, the burden of proof is on the side that wants PF to work with SA because they are making the claim. The default position is that no...
Logic is the study of valid reasoning. You used logic to say everything you said in your post. Logic is what you use when you determine to go at a...
I imagine there might be a process akin to: [attach] "What is the meaning of life? Here is your answer!"
It doesn't answer the question because (1) random GW employees answering emails is not authoritative; and, (2) emails can be faked so they are not...
Indeed, the ONLY way PF works with SA is if there is some language in the PF rule that says PF works when making SA as that is the only way there...
Silver, name another method of attacking a model not in base contact that is neither a supporting attack or monstrous support attack? Also, it is...
Screamer, Regarding your first point: while people may use the word logical to suggest their "opinion" is higher than the next man's, it is...
If all you get out of my posts are "blah blah, you're dumb, blah blah, big word, blah blah more big words because, well, lol" then I am sincerely...
Silver, is your post a response to mine? I am not entirely sure who your comments are directed at since you are quoting Screamer but it appears...
Screamer... Regarding your first point, I agree that an FAQ would be useful but ambiguity in and of itself is not reason alone or necessarily...
some interesting points raised that highlight what is at issue here. Specifically, the difference between 1 and 2 is how the rule is chosen to be...
Happy thanksgiving everyone, regardless of what you believe, roll lotsa 6s when eating your yummy foods :). To those that don't celebrate, you're...
I would but... [attach]
Regarding (1), you actually just copied and pasted a dictionary definition and more than one to boot... Pick one of those ways to define...
Hooray for constructive comments and posts!
To answer this question, my first language is Hungarian and then a bit of French (Hungarian family growing up in French part of Canada). I didn't...
A few things... Different terminology between PF and Frenzy type rules, in and of itself, is not enough to to lead the discussion in any...
Indeed, how to resolve/play PF is one thing whereas what the rules actually say or imply is another. When playing in a tournament, talk it over...
It is comments like above that probably invoke comments like below... Seriously, Markhaus, "why wouldn't it work?" Because the rules say so,...