This thread is set up to discuss and rank the comparative quality of each of the Star Wars movies. Also, on @ravagekitteh 's suggestion, hopefully this thread will be able to contain Episode vs Episode debates (alternatively they can often be described as the @Lord Agragax of Lunaxoatl vs. @NIGHTBRINGER Star Wars debates ). In any case, that is the attempt but I can offer no credible promises. Without further ado, here is my "definitive" list: BEST Episode V: The Empire Strikes Back Episode VI: Return of the Jedi Episode IV: A New Hope Episode VIII: The Last Jedi Episode VII: The Force Awakens Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Episode III: Revenge of the Sith Episode II: Attack of the Clones Episode I: The Phantom Menace WORST As of this moment, I have only seen The Last Jedi once so it could still conceivably swap places with The Force Awakens. Spoiler: The ultimate Star Wars debating thread... what could possibly go wrong? Also for the time being let's not try to spoil The Last Jedi in this thread. At least for a couple of more weeks, after which point I'd say it is fair game. I still plan to start a spoiler thread for a deeper analysis of The Last Jedi.