They did this with an Order of the Stick character Talking to a circus monster "Dinner time." "I hope it's stew!" "I've been working here for over two years and I have brought you the same stew twice a day, every day that I was here. When I started, my predecessor told me that he served the same stew every day since you were brought to the circus. It always is stew. It always will be stew. Stew is the alpha and omega of your cullinary options." "So is it stew?" (dejectedly) "Yes" "Yessssss!!!!!!"
Yeah, I don't understand what is up with the whole "cats vs cucumbers" thing. The TOASTER I get. Sudden unexpected noise. But the cucumbers? They're green vegetables. They don't DO anything. I put one next to my cats to see what happened. One tried to play with it. The second (slightly more sensible option) tried to eat it. The third went "wtf this thing is dumb leave me alone" and went back to sleep.