Same in TOW, easily the worst of our monsters. If it had swiftstride it would be close to a B I think...
I don't really prefer one over the other. I have both and the 8th edition version is what I use for an Oldblood on Carno while the 6th edition version is used for Scar Vet on Carno. I like the dynamic stance of the plastic version but the metal kit carries a lot of nostalgia for me since it was released back in my high school years.
I think the 6th edition one is much better. It's properly proportioned, while the 8th edition one has a head that looks too small for its body. The model seems better scaled to the Trogoldon head, which is a good deal larger.