He did get Inspiring Presence, but his Leadership was only 9 - and on the first roll, he rolled 11, while on the reroll, he rolled 10. He rolled pretty high on the flee roll as well. It was really one big string of bad luck, and that string continued on for the rest of the game - but that was the high point. He didn't give up then (it was a 2500 point game, so there was plenty left), but the odds were against him from then on.