The Shrine to Lost Armies

[Warden]

There were many possibilities but what I’m saying is that it’s a shame that GW never acted upon these ideas.

True, GW always followed the "tolkien" concepts of tons of heavily armored dwarfs marching on foot. Then adding cannons and gyrocopters. Some ram cavalry would have been pretty neat; those badger riders are pretty cool!

 

[Lord Agragax of Lunaxoatl]

True, GW always followed the "tolkien" concepts of tons of heavily armored dwarfs marching on foot. Then adding cannons and gyrocopters. Some ram cavalry would have been pretty neat; those badger riders are pretty cool!

Or some Dwarf Monstrous Cavalry perhaps?

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

True, GW always followed the "tolkien" concepts of tons of heavily armored dwarfs marching on foot. Then adding cannons and gyrocopters.

I always liked GW's take on this.

 

[Lord Agragax of Lunaxoatl]

I always liked GW's take on this.

It does make for a very thematic take on the Dwarfs but it is also a pain in the backside for Dwarf players like myself. You can imagine our celebrations when Storm of Magic allowed Dwarfs to take monsters as allies!

 

[Warden]

I always liked GW's take on this.

It does make for a very thematic take on the Dwarfs but it is also a pain in the backside for Dwarf players like myself. You can imagine our celebrations when Storm of Magic allowed Dwarfs to take monsters as allies!

True, it does make them very tough to play, as it feels like an uphill battle. Hurrah for the grumbling underdogs!

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

It does make for a very thematic take on the Dwarfs

In a sense, but against Dwarfs you have to remember that the opposition can't really take monsters either because they blasted off the field.

 

[Lord Agragax of Lunaxoatl]

In a sense, but against Dwarfs you have to remember that the opposition can't really take monsters either because they blasted off the field.

True - especially with the ability to take 3 cannons and the improved Organ Gun that only misfires on a double misfire!

 

[Lord-Marcus]

I've started a blog to detail a dwarf project. Inperial dwarves, to be exact

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

True - especially with the ability to take 3 cannons and the improved Organ Gun that only misfires on a double misfire!

Precisely. Besides, overall monsters weren't that effective in 8th edition (with a few exceptions). Too many armies could field cannons... and cannons were simply a hard counter to monsters.

 

[Lord-Marcus]

Precisely. Besides, overall monsters weren't that effective in 8th edition (with a few exceptions). Too many armies could field cannons... and cannons were simply a hard counter to monsters.

As they should be. Civilization and all that.

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

As they should be. Civilization and all that.

Disagree, you don't want anyone type of unit to be unplayable in the game, especially the models that are often army centerpieces.

 

[Lord-Marcus]

Disagree, you don't want anyone type of unit to be unplayable in the game, especially the models that are often army centerpieces.

This is trur. They should have some invulnerability to cannon fire

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

This is trur. They should have some invulnerability to cannon fire

Cannons should be less accurate... plain and simple. The way they were written in 8th made them laser guided sniper rifles.

 

[Lord-Marcus]

Cannons should be less accurate... plain and simple. The way they were written in 8th made them laser guided sniper rifles.

Also true. I'd rather see it miss and bounce into oncoming foot troops

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

Also true. I'd rather see it miss and bounce into oncoming foot troops

My thoughts exactly. Historically, cannons never possessed pinpoint precision.

 

[Lord-Marcus]

My thoughts exactly. Historically, cannons never possessed pinpoint precision.

I'd also like to see alternative firing modes, like grapeshot

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

I'd also like to see alternative firing modes, like grapeshot

We already have that (page 113)

 

[Lord-Marcus]

We already have that (page 113)

View attachment 40994

Where is that from?

 

[NIGHTBRINGER]

Where is that from?

Warhammer 8th Edition rule book.

 

[Lord-Marcus]

Warhammer 8th Edition rule book.

Ah. I have 6th in my library. I think I might have 7th too